|
Post by Jolly Joes on Jun 20, 2005 18:57:28 GMT -5
Pokemon(pre-KidsWB era) was(and still is) a better dub than One Piece and that was their first dubbing job.
|
|
|
Post by dead on Jun 20, 2005 20:11:05 GMT -5
If anything, One Piece is one of the WORST dubbing jobs ever. Just looking at that onepieceuncensored.tripod.com/series/ makes me ill. They're constantly cutting episodes in half and compressing them into single episodes. We've lost over eight episodes of footage so far. How can you call that a good dub at all?
|
|
Seph
Behind The Logo Team
Luigi and Marth for the win.
Posts: 3,390
|
Post by Seph on Jun 20, 2005 20:12:27 GMT -5
That sounds like Cardcaptor Sakura. Except possibly not as bad.
|
|
|
Post by dead on Jun 20, 2005 20:13:27 GMT -5
Did Cardcaptor Sakura ever take several characters who's deaths were an important part of the series, and make them not be dead anymore?
|
|
Seph
Behind The Logo Team
Luigi and Marth for the win.
Posts: 3,390
|
Post by Seph on Jun 20, 2005 20:15:35 GMT -5
I don't know the full story, but I did hear that Cardcaptor Sakura actually had the entire script rewritten, with compressed and even expanded episodes.
|
|
Toxic
Behind The Logo Team
I am also Santa Claus.
Posts: 819
|
Post by Toxic on Jun 20, 2005 20:20:23 GMT -5
But remember kids. As bad as of a dub One Piece is, it'll never be as bad as this
|
|
sonique
New Member
Don't mess with Luffy
Posts: 44
|
Post by sonique on Jun 20, 2005 20:52:08 GMT -5
ahhh thanks hmmm let's see here: onepieceuncensored.tripod.com/ - I'd be more impressed with this site if they actually had all the site working. And it's hard to read some of their... things cause of the bg colors. But the information will help me make my "What You're Missing" music video... christ they skipped the Buggy arc?.. why? www.saveluffy.tk/ - Blaze's site, right? This one is awesome and Blaze all ready gave me permission to use information on here ^_^ Everything else is just petitions. They don't work so I won't even bother with them. Thanks for the sites though. As for the uncut DVDs... well if they are released ,you're right. I shouldn't discourage people from buying them. As much as I hate to give them money, it would show more support for what the fans want... I probably stil won't buy it though =P
|
|
|
Post by dead on Jun 20, 2005 21:24:29 GMT -5
That one piece uncensored site is actually based on a famous website that detailed the cuts to DBZ's first 3 seasons (right down to the different colored boxes). That site died when he realised the dub was good.
And it is a shame that this site is missing a few episodes. If you find an episode is missing an entry, just try the next ones untill you find one that works.
|
|
|
Post by Housekeeper (loljanitor) Faddy on Jun 20, 2005 21:37:10 GMT -5
I always kind of thought the dub jobs they did were all par with each other.
Granted they aren't ear acid, but even ADV does a better job a lot of the time. Including cold-ailed Sonic and Tails. Perhaps I just care not for the punfested lines and whathaveyou. It feels so forced.
Who DOES do the worst dub jobs?
|
|
|
Post by Ice Dragon on Jun 20, 2005 21:49:10 GMT -5
4Kids.
|
|
|
Post by dead on Jun 20, 2005 22:39:44 GMT -5
|
|
Toxic
Behind The Logo Team
I am also Santa Claus.
Posts: 819
|
Post by Toxic on Jun 20, 2005 23:01:19 GMT -5
The company that did the dub of Dragonball that's been airing on YTV.
|
|
|
Post by BlazeHedgehod on Jun 20, 2005 23:54:40 GMT -5
I don't know the full story, but I did hear that Cardcaptor Sakura actually had the entire script rewritten, with compressed and even expanded episodes. More or less, yeah. Nelvana hacked the series completely into bite-sized chunks and stripped out dozens of episodes at a time. Before, I used an example that 4KIDS ran a "Chop Shop" - that defenition is more fitting for Nelvana's dub of CCS. They litterally re-wrote the entire series and spliced in clips from several different episodes to make one complete episode. I don't mean that they'd take a series of three episodes and cut them down to fit one episode - I mean they'd take clips from, say, Episodes 3, 8 and 12, salvage what they could out of them, and make one English "episode" out of that. No matter how awful any dub is, none of them will ever compare to the massacre CCS recieved. Although One Piece is certainly gaining on it. Ignoring Card Captor Sakura, One Piece is one of the most stupidly-edited animes since DiC's original Sailormoon Dub, or Saban's original Dragonball Z Dub.
|
|
PC0
Behind The Logo Team
Posts: 189
|
Post by PC0 on Jun 21, 2005 0:23:32 GMT -5
Okay, I just got up, and I really don't feel like putting up with PC0, so I'll summarize this. Yeah. You're annoying, you're fanatical, and quite frankly, you act really stupid over silly things. Even Sonique didn't get her bunches all in a knot over my comments, something that really suprised (and pleased) me. Ever notice why the people around you aren't so 'passionate', PC0? Because it's zealotry and fanaticsm, dumbass. (Afternote-- Just as a counter to me being in the FUS community, no, I wasn't, but I sure as hell was left in the wake of it -- thus my annoyance. NEX--wait, what) Stop acting all high and mighty, you're not some 'high lord' able to pass judgement on others and honestly, calling me a zealot when you're going off on a tangent of flaming and insults is pretty hypocritical. But whatever, believe what you want, you're entitled to an opinion.
|
|
Seph
Behind The Logo Team
Luigi and Marth for the win.
Posts: 3,390
|
Post by Seph on Jun 21, 2005 0:51:48 GMT -5
I'm definitely not high-and-mighty, Mr. PC0, however I had a perfect reason to do this, even if it has been a while since it happened. And believe it or not, it tied into the topic.
... actually, I'll work this line by line, again.
I wasn't. This is designed to feign some charge against me, when I was thrashing for a legit reason (although I have already admitted that I thrashed a bit too hard)
By thinking anything of me, you're passing judgement. Everyone passes judgement. It's only when some action that restricts you from daily life or living normally is taken that I'm 'passing judgement' in the sense you mean. And if I am, then you are one sorry soul.
A) I was talking about your response to Teflon, really. B) Let's see my hideous insults. First, I criticized Sonique. Though it was done harshly, I didn't outright insult her. Then, she replied that it was a success. I responded with another harsh point, calling it a failure. Still not insulting or hilariously flaming her, by the way, I don't believe I've called her any names ('you' in the post refers to a collective, and it's well known that they WERE zealots) aside from 'idiotic', but only for the idea that she eventually repealed herself. In fact, this post gave me a LEGITAMATE reason for doing what I was (backed up only minorly by Sz).
... Wow, who threw the first real insults? You? Amazing!
PC0, remember that time when Sonic360 was here, and you went apeshit on him for a well-meaning PM to Blaze? In fact, it's probably safe to say you're a major reason a forum member who was finally coming to his senses left-- someone who could have been a productive member of our community. Did you see Sonique losing her cool? Did you ever stop to think that your friends don't need some hero to come in, guns blazing? I understand that you want to defend them, but Sonique handled the entire situation very professionally, while you (and I, admittedly) didn't.
Finally, this contradicts with your first statement. An opinion is a judgement.
EDIT: To lighten the mood a bit, 69th post! Whoo! *bricked*
|
|
|
Post by BlazeHedgehod on Jun 21, 2005 0:56:01 GMT -5
Could you guys please lay off? This isn't the "Seph and PC0 argue about a 10 year old conversation" topic, thisi s about One Piece and the bastardization thereof. Certainly, there is a PM system, at the very least.
|
|
Seph
Behind The Logo Team
Luigi and Marth for the win.
Posts: 3,390
|
Post by Seph on Jun 21, 2005 0:58:10 GMT -5
._. *goes to room*
|
|
sonique
New Member
Don't mess with Luffy
Posts: 44
|
Post by sonique on Jun 21, 2005 1:00:05 GMT -5
But it wasn't a failure, that's why Satam is airing in several countries now and doing well ;_;
|
|
Seph
Behind The Logo Team
Luigi and Marth for the win.
Posts: 3,390
|
Post by Seph on Jun 21, 2005 1:28:14 GMT -5
I was only quoting for the sake of accuracy. =P
|
|
|
Post by Merry Smindmas on Jun 21, 2005 5:22:24 GMT -5
Hmm, but keep in mind these are kids. From what everyone in this topic has been saying, OP sounds pretty brutal - I really doubt kids would like it =P That didn't stop them from watching DBZ. DBZ was edited though to remove the properly brutal amounts of blood in it.
|
|